logoalt Hacker News

Gormotoday at 4:23 PM3 repliesview on HN

> In other words --- pure greed.

Pure greed would have a strong incentive to understand what the market is actually demanding in order to maximize profits.

These attempts to try to steer demand despite clear indicators that it doesn't want to go in that direction aren't just driven by greed, they're driven by abject incompetence.

This isn't pure greed, it's stupid greed.


Replies

wubrrtoday at 4:56 PM

Pure greed is stupid greed.

Also, if the current level of AI investment and valuations aren't justified by market demand (I believe so), many of these people/companies are getting more money than they would without the unreasonable hype.

binary132today at 5:13 PM

you seem to be committing the error of believing that the problem here is just that they’re not selling what people want to buy, instead of identifying the clear intention to _create_ the market.

paganeltoday at 4:58 PM

> Pure greed would have a strong incentive to understand what the market is actually demanding in order to maximize profits.

Not necessarily, just look at this clip [1] from Margin Call, an excellent movie on the GFC. As Jeremy Irons is saying in that clip, the market (as usually understood in classical economy, with producers making things for clients/customers to purchase) is of no importance to today's market economy, almost all that matters, at the hundreds of billions - multi-trillion dollars-levels, is for your company "to play the music" as best as the other (necessarily very big) market participants, "nothing more, nothing less" (again, to quote Irons in that movie).

There's nothing in it about "making what people/customers want" and all that, which is regarded as accessory, that is if it is taken into consideration at all. As another poster is mentioning in this thread, this is all the direct result of the financialization of much of the Western economy, this is how things work at this level, given these (financiliazed) inputs.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UOYi4NzxlhE