logoalt Hacker News

US will now review H-1B applicants' social media – require them to make public

13 pointsby JKCalhountoday at 6:48 PM11 commentsview on HN

Comments

arjietoday at 7:20 PM

When I filed my last DS-160 for my final H-1B renewal before I got my green card, I remember filling in my social media identifiers. In fact, a look at a 2019 document reveals that providing the identifiers has been required since at least back then[0]. Given that the identifiers must be offered, the intent must be that the posts should be read, so this is unsurprising[1].

I suppose one happy fact from this must be that USCIS has never had convenient access to dragnet surveillance. For if they did, they would simply have used the backdoor rather than ask you to make the profile public. For my part, I always assumed that the US Government knew everything I posted.

I'm sure that if they didn't like me for some reason, they'd find a Richelieu accusation to make from what I've written. One would imagine it is like that other self-evident thing in the First Amendment, "separation of church and state", that is also practiced where convenient and not otherwise. Unless born American (and perhaps now, also "to Americans born American") some degree of scepticism for the tenets of the American Civil Religion will serve anyone well.

0: https://travel.state.gov/content/dam/visas/Enhanced%20Vettin...

1: I'm sure someone could construct machinery where a blacklist is produced by one arm of the government with view to posts which is used by another arm that which has no post-access but I think that was unlikely when this was designed

arealaccounttoday at 7:06 PM

How does this work if you don't have social media accounts?

show 1 reply
mikeyousetoday at 7:19 PM

They’re also going to ban you and all of your relatives from receiving a Visa if you’ve previously worked in content moderation, fact-checking, trust/safety. The most free speech hostile administration in modern history.

https://www.reuters.com/world/us/trump-administration-orders...

rose-knuckle17today at 7:12 PM

Hopefully a consequence of that will be the rest of the world actively telling its people that america is probably a less healthy regime for them than countries like China and discouraging all recreational, educational and employment travel here, under any circumstances - including the desires and fetishes of unregulated capitalism.

We are currently test driving the arbitrary execution of anyone without due process to see if THAT finally wakes up the population. But it wont.

show 2 replies
dmitrygrtoday at 7:02 PM

A country may vet entrants according to any criteria it chooses, just like I may enforce any limits I wish unto who may enter my house. If the criteria are too egregious for the gain the applicants might get by being in that country, the talented immigrants who have options may go elsewhere and the country may need relax the criteria to recapture the market for bright minds.

show 3 replies