logoalt Hacker News

mytailorisrichtoday at 10:47 AM2 repliesview on HN

Lobbying is part of the democratic process. There are many interests in society and it is right that their voices be heard and considered by the government and parliament when deciding on law and policy.

It is important that there be rules to keep things transparent but lobbying is not a problem in itself.

A simplistic example might be: Let's say that a group calls for a ban on all vehicles then it is right for groups relying on vehicles to make their voice heard to explain what the negative impact would be. Once government and parliament have heard all sides then they can make up their mind. If whole groups are banned from expressing their point of view and from defending their interests then it is no longer a democratic free society.

Interference by foreign powers is a different thing altogether.

Calls to ban lobbying are the usual "slippery slope" that leads to authoritarianism.


Replies

grafmaxtoday at 11:12 AM

Your voice being heard is one thing. What we have here is the consequence of huge wealth disparities. Those with the money can influence the “democratic” process in outsized ways. That is the opposite of democratic.

show 2 replies
jack_trippertoday at 11:17 AM

> lobbying is not a problem in itself.

It kinda is though, since massive sums of money never comes for free with no strings attached but favors are expected in return. And those strings attached typically are to undermine the best interest of the working class to enrich those paying the lobby money.

>Calls to ban lobbying is the usual "slippery slope" that leads to authoritarianism.

Where do you see me calling to ban lobbying?