logoalt Hacker News

Jolla Phone Pre-Order

148 pointsby jhohotoday at 3:15 PM105 commentsview on HN

Comments

mhitzatoday at 4:04 PM

47% percent of voters wanted a ~6" phone, and 12% of voters a ~7" phone.

I guess me and the remaining 41% of voters are still left wishing for 5" phones to make a comeback.

show 4 replies
raphinoutoday at 5:10 PM

Can it be reinstalled with a standard linux (for me at the end of it's life)? That would make me buy it.

rckttoday at 4:04 PM

It would be great if all these companies contributed to a some kind of a unified modular platform like Project ARA. I see a lot of new devices, but they all do their own stuff. They produce hardware for their software, the end result is the same as with big brands. Most of these devices are usable while they are supported by these companies. Some of them allow installing custom Android roms, but not many.

Looks like the market just gets more fragmented without any improvements towards better sustainability/reusability. The only thing that really caught my attention recently was Pilet, a handheld Raspberry Pi. That's a really cool thing, that gives mobility while maintaining functionality.

show 2 replies
Nifty3929today at 4:08 PM

I love the idea of the privacy switch, but I want more: I want a hard, electromechanical switch for each of: Mic, camera, GPS, wifi, cell, bluetooth. These can be tiny and aesthetically pleasing, as long as I can easily flip on/off the one I want.

The problem with having a single button, even configurable, is that it's all-or-nothing, and I might want different things at different times.

But thanks so much for taking the first step!

show 2 replies
cboltontoday at 4:44 PM

The Linux phone that's more closed than Android, it's a hard sell for me.

show 2 replies
abnercoimbretoday at 3:49 PM

> Entering other markets, such as the U.S. and Canada are to be decided due course based on potential interest from the areas.

As an American, I will order this phone as soon as it’s available to me!

I’m not aware of any similar option for us at the moment so I’m a little sad.

show 2 replies
dethostoday at 4:55 PM

I'm a bit torn about this. On one hand, I really think viable alternatives to Android/iOS are now more necessary than ever, and I'm eager to explore this OS. On the other hand, I'm not in the mood to buy new hardware (right now) just to try it out.

Nevertheless, I hope they succeed.

storustoday at 4:59 PM

HMD under NOKIA brand went almost out of business due to adding notches to their phones, now Jolla is doing the same mistake. Only Apple could get away with it. At least they aren't shipping a 720p display anymore. Why didn't they just replicate/rebrand Xperia?

mathgeektoday at 4:59 PM

> Pre-Order Now for 99 €

Is this something generally understood to be a down payment in EU nomenclature? Just curiosity, as in the US I'd generally expect it to mean you get a phone on launch for the stated price, and a down payment to use something along the lines of "reserve for...".

Telaneotoday at 5:04 PM

Low hopes and low expectations given Jollas previous dealings, not to mention Linux phones' typical issues. But one can hope.

parasitidtoday at 3:40 PM

it's based on a proprietary os, which includes halium proprietary blobs.

imho, linux users should focus on phones well supported by postmarketos

show 1 reply
ramon156today at 4:45 PM

> A successor to the iconic original Jolla Phone from 2013

does anyone own this 2013 version? why did it not crash the market?

Also, will my banking app be supported on sailfishOS?

show 2 replies
monerozcashtoday at 4:35 PM

>User configurable physical Privacy Switch - turn off you microphone, bluetooth, Android apps, or whatever you wish

sus

I don't think it is a good idea to call this a "privacy switch", obviously it works in software and can't be trusted.

show 1 reply
mongoltoday at 3:38 PM

What is Jolla now? I remember it as startup created by previous Nokia employees that tried to build a Nokia-type of phone based on Maemo? Or do I remember it wrong?

show 2 replies
ttkaritoday at 3:32 PM

Hardware specs look pretty nice, SailfishOS should work nicely on this device. The design language remains faithful to the original Jolla Phone from more than a decade ago. :)

rzerowantoday at 3:53 PM

Seems they still havent figured out a business model for their OS. Hardware at low volumes wont move ala kickstarter.

Would have thought after their ups and downs they would have landedon a sustainable businesss model. The market oppurtunity is there and the timing is favourable. All thats needed to stick the landing and have a viable alt to the ios/android duoploly.

Personally would recommend they work with an established OEM to customize/port drivers to existing hardware and market to a specific vertical rather than a general purpose for normies device.

show 1 reply
dzinktoday at 4:34 PM

Show the operating system. That is the core of what people will be using - they need to know what it looks like. How easy it is. The phone looks like all other phones.

show 2 replies
stiraytoday at 4:58 PM

I wouldnt recommend it.

I had Sailfish OS for a daily driver for two years, and OS is great (let me say that again, Sailfish IS GREAT!), but there are "the details".

Jolla is completely ignorant to needs of their users. While they do have an android layer, they are ignoring things that are of huge importance for daily life, like bluetooth passtrough, and are important due to daily needs, for instance, bluetooth passtrough is really important for using public transport here.

FFS, I was reversing banking application and patching it to be able to use it. And actually became very good at it :D

Here is a bluetooth feature request thread, that is open for 5 years: https://forum.sailfishos.org/t/bluetooth-support-in-android

So at the end you will have a great OS, incompatible with the whole world. I ditched it and installed Graphene OS.

Once Jolla starts to listen to their customers, they are on the path to very real android contender, but unfortunately they just dont understand, that people need some features, they are not providing while the vendors wont support some exotic OS. They need to adapt, not vendors - the whole thread is full of this mentality.

The android "container" was a step into right direction but they just shouldnt abandone it and keep on supporting it.

I really hope they will change their mind at some point and prioritize compatibility, would love to ditch android and its spyware driven ecosystem completely, but sadly, Graphene OS is just a far better alternative until jolla stops behaving like an infant.

show 2 replies
afandiantoday at 4:10 PM

I went down a 1-minute rabbithole. I hate Whatsapp, but it's not optional. So I was curious if it's compatible.

There's a Sailfish help page [0] showing how to get the APK from Aptoide, or downloading directly from Whatsapp.com .

But with Google killing off 'sideloading', is it credible that independent APK sources are going to dry up in future?

[0] https://docs.sailfishos.org/Support/Help_Articles/Whatsapp_S...

show 1 reply
onlitoday at 3:35 PM

Awesome, this has a user replaceable battery! Sadly I do see no headphone jack, so not an option for me. Did I miss it on the pictures?

show 2 replies
tetris11today at 3:37 PM

Add a keyboard, and you would have piqued my interest.

I dont understand how ex-Nokia devs could have built a phone like the N900 and then just walked away from it for 15 years

show 3 replies
dmantoday at 4:47 PM

Fool me once shame on you.

Fool me twice shame on me.

Jolla never shipped me a tablet or offered me a refund back when they were making tablets. I would strongly urge people not to pre-order from the company since they have a track record of not shipping and being extremely irresponsible in their communications when they dont ship.

show 1 reply
999900000999today at 4:23 PM

No jack, meaning I'll have to fight a hacked together Bluetooth implementation. Its an interesting project, but not for me.

show 2 replies
Nifty3929today at 4:10 PM

"... It is governed by European privacy ..." - This is not inspiring in today's climate.

I hope instead it's governed by a principal of people's privacy.

Paiannitoday at 4:38 PM

I hope they've learned their lesson after the tablet fiasco.

kogepathictoday at 4:20 PM

Hard no on giving Jolla a cent. Jolla rug-pulled [1] people who crowd-funded [2] their tablet in 2014.

Jolla used the crowd-funding campaign to butter up VCs for their next funding round [3] and then decided the Asian LLC handling the crowdfunding would go bankrupt, leaving backers with no tablets and most with no refund. [4]

The real kicker was that the tablets were ALREADY manufactured by their ODM, Jolla just never paid them. Took backers money and stiffed their manufacturing partner too. For a while after the campaign folded you could buy Jolla branded tablets (running Android, it was just an ODM model they flashed Sailfish on) on eBay or Taobao [5]. I just checked and there's a Jolla Tablet listed on eBay right now. [6]

10 years later, it looks like they're trying the same thing. Maybe they think the internet has forgotten, but I have zero interest in supporting their next hardware rug-pull endeavour.

[1] https://together.jolla.com/question/97695/information-regard...

[2] https://www.indiegogo.com/en/projects/jolla/jolla-tablet-wor...

[3] https://jolla.com/content/uploads/2017/02/46_JOLLATABLET_STR...

[4] https://blog.jolla.com/second_phase_refund/

[5] https://old.reddit.com/r/Jolla/comments/3x2s7e/jolla_tablets...

[6] https://archive.ph/Ncf17

show 3 replies
aapoalastoday at 3:59 PM

I low-key hate myself for this, but I went and preorder. I've been waiting for SFOS to come to my Xperia 10 IV but that seems to still be in beta, and after quite a few years it'd be hard to switch over ask well... But I have to try support Jolla as they've been my go-to phone OS maker for the last 10-15 years.

ThePowerOfFuettoday at 4:59 PM

They'll have my money if they meet the requirements for GrapheneOS.

show 2 replies
pajkotoday at 4:11 PM

Based on a Mediatek CPU, so not for me.

alex_duftoday at 4:09 PM

wow, I never expected to see them come back

NoSalttoday at 4:33 PM

> "Markets: EU, UK, Norway and Switzerland"

Well, crap!

jeffbeetoday at 4:58 PM

"Real Linux on a phone" sounds to me like the worst user experience imaginable. And the whole thing about "no phoning home" should be interpreted as "we have no idea whether the latest release is crashing in the wild or not".

show 1 reply
fodmaptoday at 4:14 PM

Don't confuse Jolla https://jolla.com/ with Volla https://volla.online/en/index.php

Both are European companys with a great privacy drive.

show 3 replies