logoalt Hacker News

jtf23yesterday at 6:50 PM4 repliesview on HN

profits have not materialized, nor can they: machines can only transfer value, they cannot create it


Replies

mikepurvisyesterday at 7:16 PM

Two responses to this:

- Most participants in the economy are creating very little real value. They're shifting things around or temporarily solving problems that are highly localized to the organization they're in.

- There's a lot of unrealized value stored in the corpus of knowledge that AI companies have ingested— the millions of webpages, the scanned books, wikipedia, the blogs and Q&A sites. So even if AI companies are not creating new insights, just the act of locating, filtering, and summarizing knowledge that was already present somewhere in the world is valuable. Indeed, one could use this same argument to declare that Google in 1999 was creating no value, which is of course obviously untrue.

show 1 reply
ubercow13yesterday at 6:53 PM

What?

show 1 reply