logoalt Hacker News

JumpCrisscrosslast Saturday at 11:59 PM2 repliesview on HN

One, I'm not sure what American founding ideals have to do with Germany.

Two, Germany, like most countries and frankly human populations, has a male surplus in its fighting-age population [1]. This is why, historically, large socities tended to wage war with men first. (Even those that e.g. held elite units in reserve, which undermines the usual biological argument.)

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Germany#/media...


Replies

throw310822last Sunday at 12:05 AM

The male surplus is a few tens of thousands, way to small to make up an army; and no, that is not the reason why men and not women go to war.

show 2 replies
throwawaypathlast Sunday at 4:37 PM

>has a male surplus in its fighting-age population

The "male surplus fighting-age population" in Germany will flee to the next European host or back to the MENA country they fled from if conscription begins.