logoalt Hacker News

m000last Sunday at 12:26 AM1 replyview on HN

You probably have no idea what you're talking about. Mandatory conscription (which I have personally served) is for a fixed term, so your livelihood is not tied to the army paying your salary. It's more of a semi-unpleasant mandatory intermission in your life plans.

Also, if you have decades of mandatory conscription then there is no slope to slip. Germany on the other hand is now on a slope, since they regress from a fully professional army back to conscription. How much down they will slip, remains to be seen.


Replies

JumpCrisscrosslast Sunday at 12:27 AM

> Mandatory conscription

Active != mandatory.

> Mandatory conscription (which I have personally served) is for a fixed term, so your livelihood is not tied to the army paying your salary

You're seriously arguing that countries with mandatory conscription are less militarised than those with active (but not mandatory) conscription?

show 1 reply