logoalt Hacker News

defrostlast Sunday at 6:01 AM2 repliesview on HN

A lack of antibiotics wasn't sufficient reason to stay in western society for those members of the Pintupi Nine and other hunter gather families that came in, looked about, and left again.

Some can't imagine life without antibiotics, others can't fathom living with everything else that comes with it.


Replies

Alohalast Sunday at 7:54 AM

They had a place that was familiar and comforting to go return to.

Anyone who is of a modern industrialized society who is waxing poetically about becoming a hunter gatherer is both, looking at history thru very rose colored goggles and welcome to go find a place to do just that.

show 1 reply
tor825gllast Sunday at 8:47 AM

But you've selected one particular group. The thousands of groups and individuals who merged their way of life with that of farming/toolmaking/industrialised/modern human society do not have a name, they are just part of the human mainstream.

Of course some of these adaptations happened by force or coercion. But many didn't. So many groups have wanted to participate in technological progress, even at the cost of giving up their previous way of life, that in fact extreme degrees of control and/or hostility have often been needed just to keep parallel societies uncontacted.

show 1 reply