logoalt Hacker News

logicproglast Sunday at 11:42 AM2 repliesview on HN

The "original affluent society" theory is based on several false premises and is fundamentally outdated, but people keep it alive because it fits certain Rousseauean assumptions we have. I recommend reading this:

https://kk.org/mt-files/reCCearch-mt/kaplan-darker.pdf

There are so many things wrong with those time estimates.


Replies

BDPWlast Sunday at 2:50 PM

I just read the 'original affluent society' and (most of) your linked essay, I kind of agree with you. That said, the conclusions of Kaplan lead to estimates or 35-60 hours a week (excluding some depending on the group) and that surprised me a lot. That's very different from the image I got from some other comments in this thread talking about extremely long days with constant back-breaking work. Would you agree?

show 1 reply
analog8374last Sunday at 2:19 PM

Well don't just accuse, insinuate and link. Lay out a few actual assertions.

show 1 reply