alt Hacker News> since LLM generated content is not copyrightable
That's not how it works. If you ask an LLM to write Harry Potter and it writes something that is 99% the same as Harry Potter, it isn't magically free of copyright. That would obviously be insane.
The legal system is still figuring out exactly what the rules are here but it seems likely that it's going to be on the LLM user to know if the output is protected by copyright. I imagine AI vendors will develop secondary search thingies to warn you (if they haven't already), and there will probably be some "reasonable belief" defence in the eventual laws.
Either way it definitely isn't as simple as "LLM wrote it so we can ignore copyright".
Replies
I think the poster is looking at it from the other way: purely machine-generated content is not generally copryrightable, even if it can violate copyright. So it's more a question of can a coplyleft license like GPL actually protect something that's original but primarily LLM generated? Should it do so?
(From what I understand, the amount of human input that's required to make the result copyrightable can be pretty small, perhaps even as little as selecting from multiple options. But this is likely to be quite a gray area.)
>it seems likely that it's going to be on the LLM user to know if the out is protected by copyright.
To me, this is what seems more insane! If you've never read Harry Potter, and you ask an LLM to write you a story about a wizard boy, and it outputs 80% Harry Potter - how would you even know?
> there will be probably be some "reasonable belief" defence in eventual laws.
This is probably true, but it's irksome to shift all blame away from the LLM producers, using copy-written data to peddle copy-written output. This simply turns the business into copyright infringement as a service - what incentive would they have to actually build those "secondary search thingies" and build them well?
> it definitely isn't as simple as "LLM wrote it so we can ignore copyright".
Agreed. The copyright system is getting stress tested. It will be interesting to see how our legal systems can adapt to this.