logoalt Hacker News

Kim_Bruningtoday at 2:06 AM2 repliesview on HN

Amanda Askell studied under David Chalmers at NYU: the philosopher who coined "the hard problem of consciousness" and is famous for taking phenomenal experience seriously rather than explaining it away. That context makes her choice to speak this way more striking: this isn't naive anthropomorphizing from someone unfamiliar with the debates. It's someone trained by one of the most rigorous philosophers of consciousness, who knows all the arguments for dismissing mental states in non-biological systems, and is still choosing to speak carefully about models potentially having something like feelings or insecurities.


Replies

habinerotoday at 9:35 AM

A person can study fashion extensively, under the best designers, they can understand tailoring and fit and have a phenomenal eye for color and texture.

Their vivid descriptions of what the Emperor could be wearing doesn't make said emperor any less nakey.