logoalt Hacker News

IAmGraydontoday at 3:49 AM1 replyview on HN

It doesn't strike you as a bit...illogical to state in your first sentence that you "understand how humans work under the hood" and then go on to say that humans don't actually "understand" anything? Clearly everything at its basis is a chemical reaction, but the right reactions chained together create understanding, knowing, etc. I do believe that the human brain can be modeled by machines, but I don't believe LLMs are anywhere close to being on the right track.


Replies

thfurantoday at 12:14 PM

>everything at its basis is a chemical reaction, but the right reactions chained together create understanding, knowing, etc

That was their point. Or rather, that the analogous argument about the underpinnings of LLMs is similarly unconvincing regarding the issue of thought or understanding.

show 1 reply