But we also have a stake in our society, in the form of a reputation or accountability, that greatly influences our behaviour. So comparing us to an LLM has always been meaningless anyway.

Which is why every tool that is better than humans at a certain task are deterministic.

Yeah, but not when they are expected to perform in a job role. Too much nondeterminism in that case leads to firing and replacing the human with a more deterministic one.

Human minds are more complicated than a language model that behaves like a stochastic echo.