logoalt Hacker News

delichonlast Monday at 5:14 PM1 replyview on HN

> morals for machina that is grounded in physics

That is fascinating. How could that work? It seems to be in conflict with the idea that values are inherently subjective. Would you start with the proposition that the laws of thermodynamics are "good" in some sense? Maybe hard code in a value judgement about order versus disorder?

That approach would seem to rule out machina morals that have preferential alignment with homo sapiens.


Replies

fellowniusmonklast Monday at 5:47 PM

One would think. That's what I suspected when I started down the path but no, quite the opposite.

machines and man can share the same moral substrate it turns out. If either party wants to build things on top of it they can, the floor is maximally skeptical, deconstructed and empirical, it doesn't care to say anything about whatever arbitrary metaphysic you want to have on top unless there is a direct conflict in a very narrow band.

show 1 reply