logoalt Hacker News

uplifterlast Monday at 5:15 PM2 repliesview on HN

> An objective and grounded ethical framework that applies to all agents should be a top priority.

Sounds like a petrified civilization.

In the later Dune books, the protagonist's solution to this risk was to scatter humanity faster than any global (galactic) dictatorship could take hold. Maybe any consistent order should be considered bad?


Replies

yifanllast Monday at 5:51 PM

Notably, Dune is a work of fiction.

show 2 replies
fellowniusmonklast Monday at 5:42 PM

This is a narrow and incorrect view of morality. Correct morality might increase or decrease, call for extreme growth or shutdown, be realist or anti-realist. Saying morality necessarily petrifies is incorrect.

Most people's only exposure to claims of objective morals are through divine command so it's understandable. The core of morality has to be the same as philosophy, what is true, what is real, what are we? Then can you generate any shoulds? Qualified based on entity type or not, modal or not.

show 1 reply