logoalt Hacker News

cycomaniclast Tuesday at 7:52 AM3 repliesview on HN

MDs are just another example of Sony screwing it up by making things proprietary and keeping it to themselves instead of creating an ecosystem (memory sticks were another example, although they didn't offer quite the same advantages). It's really a shame, I think if Sony would have gone about this differently they likely would have put off the emergence of MP3 players for a long time.


Replies

MrSkelterlast Tuesday at 10:39 AM

It’s a funny comment because those formats only existed to be proprietary. Sony learnt the wrong lessons from CD, which they co developed with Phillips. They saw the success of that format and wished they were getting royalties on the underlying tech.

They then wasted billions and decades in formats other companies wouldn’t touch because they had fees attached. Minidisc being a prime example. Sounded worse than CDs, cost the same. Had a recording feature people already had with cassette.

ofrzetalast Tuesday at 1:48 PM

MD was quite conventient for recording (interviews, ambient ...) and with random access much better than cassettes.

actionfromafarlast Tuesday at 8:57 AM

And it could have been the successor to the floppy

show 2 replies