logoalt Hacker News

troupolast Tuesday at 2:07 PM1 replyview on HN

No. It's laziness and bad design. It's the most generic trash icon from the most generic icon set.

Same with "add row above/below" or the completely distinct action Create Filter/Filter by cell value.

They can be trivially improved with about 1 millisecond of conscious thought. Especially given the fact that these actions have been around in office software for literal decades, and more often than not with their own distinct icons.


Replies

crazygringolast Tuesday at 2:20 PM

I don't know how they can be trivially improved.

I vaguely recall seeing some product with toolbar icons that attempted to depict a cell as part of a row, or column, with an "x" in the corner to indicate delete. I could never decipher them. It was all too small. Plus the "x" looked just like the "+" at a glance since it was so small. Even though every icon was distinct and meaningful, each icon was also ultimately a complicated jumble that took longer to decipher than just reading the label next to it.

So when you say "They can be trivially improved with about 1 millisecond of conscious thought," I completely disagree. It's actually really hard and there's a good reason they choose not to. And maybe don't be so insulting?

show 1 reply