alt Hacker NewsLook interesting, eager to play around with it! Devstral was a neat model when it released and one of the better ones to run locally for agentic coding. Nowadays I mostly use GPT-OSS-120b for this, so gonna be interesting to see if Devstral 2 can replace it.
I'm a bit saddened by the name of the CLI tool, which to me implies the intended usage. "Vibe-coding" is a fun exercise to realize where models go wrong, but for professional work where you need tight control over the quality, you can obviously not vibe your way to excellency, hard reviews are required, so not "vibe coding" which is all about unreviewed code and just going with whatever the LLM outputs.
But regardless of that, it seems like everyone and their mother is aiming to fuel the vibe coding frenzy. But where are the professional tools, meant to be used for people who don't want to do vibe-coding, but be heavily assisted by LLMs? Something that is meant to augment the human intellect, not replace it? All the agents seem to focus on off-handing work to vibe-coding agents, while what I want is something even tighter integrated with my tools so I can continue delivering high quality code I know and control. Where are those tools? None of the existing coding agents apparently aim for this...
Replies
>vibe-coding
A surprising amount of programming is building cardboard services or apps that only need to last six months to a year and then thrown away when temporary business needs change. Execs are constantly clamoring for semi-persistent dashboards and ETL visualized data that lasts just long enough to rein in the problem and move on to the next fire. Agentic coding is good enough for cardboard services that collapse when they get wet. I wouldn't build an industrial data lake service with it, but you can certainly build cardboard consumers of the data lake.
> But where are the professional tools, meant to be used for people who don't want to do vibe-coding, but be heavily assisted by LLMs? Something that is meant to augment the human intellect, not replace it?
Claude Code not good enough for ya?
> where are the professional tools, meant to be used for people who don't want to do vibe-coding, but be heavily assisted by LLMs?
This is what we're building at Brokk: https://brokk.ai/
Quick intro: https://blog.brokk.ai/introducing-lutz-mode/
I created a very unprofessional tool, which apparently does what you want!
While True:
0. Context injected automatically. (My repos are small.)
1. I describe a change.
2. LLM proposes a code edit. (Can edit multiple files simultaneously. Only one LLM call required :)
3. I accept/reject the edit.
High quality code is a thing from the past
What matters is high quality specifications including test cases
> run locally for agentic coding. Nowadays I mostly use GPT-OSS-120b for this
What kind of hardware do you have to be able to run a performant GPT-OSS-120b locally?
Their new CLI agent tool [1] is written in Python unlike similar agents from Anthropic/Google (Typescript/Bun) and OpenAI (Rust). It also appears to have first class ACP support, where ACP is the new protocol from Zed [2].
[1] https://github.com/mistralai/mistral-vibe
[2] https://zed.dev/acp