logoalt Hacker News

greyface-yesterday at 7:44 PM3 repliesview on HN

New baseline expectation that web traffic will be encrypted on the wire: very good!

New de-facto requirement that you need to receive the blessing of a CA to make use of basic web platform features... not so good.


Replies

ekr____yesterday at 7:54 PM

Can you elaborate a bit about what you mean by "the blessing of a CA"?

I agree that it's true that you need a certificate to do TLS, but importantly Let's Encrypt isn't interested in what you do with your certificate, just that you actually control the domain name. See: https://letsencrypt.org/2015/10/29/phishing-and-malware.html

show 1 reply
jovial_cavalieryesterday at 7:50 PM

That's not new, LetsEncrypt just didn't solve it. And if you think this is the only single point of failure in the stack, I have news for you.

show 1 reply
unethical_banyesterday at 8:37 PM

Kinda hear you, but DNS is a defacto requirement as well. Neither DNS (common TLDs) nor any of the major cert vendors I'm aware of ask you your site's business before issuing.

show 1 reply