logoalt Hacker News

UncleMeat12/09/20252 repliesview on HN

I do not see the difference between property taxes on my home and property taxes on my stock portfolio. What makes wealth taxes bad?


Replies

orangecat12/09/2025

Property taxes are use taxes. You're paying for the right to occupy an inherently limited resource, and for necessary services and infrastructure. It's not a wealth tax because it doesn't matter how much equity you have; it's the same whether you fully paid in cash or have an interest-only mortgage. It's also not a capital gains tax because the purchase price doesn't matter.

show 1 reply
quesera12/09/2025

A corporation does not provide services to shareholders.

A municipality is charging residents for services. Obligations are progressive (by necessity), and indexed to assessed property value (as a practicality), rather than equity or income.

Municipal operations get more expensive with inflation, and with resident demands (ballot initiatives, etc). They are never zero, and must be tied to something in the real world.

These payments are collected as a tax, because that is the only lever available to municipalities.

I see your point, but I think it's a category error.

You are taxed on realized property capital gains, beyond a certain amount ($500K?) for principal residence (anywhere you've lived two of more of the last five years). And for a non-principal residence there is no threshold.

show 1 reply