logoalt Hacker News

_ache_today at 4:10 AM2 repliesview on HN

Looks very fake. Self published (Anima-Core is NOT a journal), no academic anteriority, very strong statement, no peer-review, no public history of technical skills. Did I mention the use of Github via the interface only?

At the same time, possible since it's only classification tasks. I mean, the method explained is technically plausible, a lot of people thought about it, we were just unable to find a method to do so.

Very unlikely true, unfortunately.


Replies

MrDrMcCoytoday at 7:04 AM

Did you not see the author's note about being an outsider to academia? Not everyone has the background to pull all that off. This is an earnest attempt to come as close as possible and they even invite feedback that would help it become a real academic submission.

hirako2000today at 6:32 AM

Have you run the walk-through to reproduce? They provide a highly detailed step by step document. They welcome raising an issue if reproduction doesn't yield the claimed results within 2%.

It's OK to call out fake claims. But it requires going through the process if such is reasonable, it just seems to take a couple of hours to find out.

show 1 reply