'pcwalton, I'm coming for you. You're going down.
Kidding aside, the comments it picks out for us are a little random. For instance, this was an A+ predictive thread (it appears to be rating threads and not individual comments):
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10703512
But there's just 11 comments, only 1 for me, and it's like a 1-sentence comment.
I do love that my unaccredited-access-to-startup-shares take is on that leaderboard, though.
Yeah, I'm having to pinch myself a little here. Another slightly odd example it picked out from your history: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10735398
It's a good comment, but "prescient" isn't a word I'd apply to it. This is more like a list of solid takes. To be fair there probably aren't even that many explicit, correct predictions in one month of comments in 2015.
Hilariously, it seems you anticipated this happening and copyrighted your comments. Is karpathy's tool in violation of your copyright?!
I noticed from reviewing my own entry (which honestly I'm surprised exists) that the idea of what it thinks constitutes a "prediction" is fairly open to interpretation, or at least that adding some nuance to a small aspect in a thread to someone else prediction counts quite heavily. I don't really view how I've participated here over the years in any way as making predictions. I actually thought I had done a fairly good job at not making predictions, by design.