alt Hacker NewsThis isn't true in practice because you won't be able to control where allocations are made in the dependencies you use, including inside the Go standard library itself. You could rewrite/fork that code, but then you lose access to the Go ecosystem.
The big miss of the OP is that it ignores the Go region proposal, which is using lessons learned from this project to solve the issue in a more tractable way. So while Arenas won't be shipped as they were originally envisioned, it isn't to say no progress is being made.
I had to fork go’s CSV to make it re-use buffers and avoid defensive copies. But im not sure an arena api is a panacea here - even if i can supply an arena, the library needs certain guarantees about how memory it returns is aliased / used by the caller. Maybe it would still defensive copy into the arena, maybe not. So i don’t see how taking arena as parameter lets a function reason about how safely it can use the arena.