logoalt Hacker News

palmotea12/11/20251 replyview on HN

> Re: timing - They were triggered to explode en masse, which implies that there was zero consideration to minimizing civilian harm.

Zero? The whole nature of the attack shows consideration towards "minimizing civilian harm." Tricking an enemy agent into carrying a small explosive device on his person, then detonating it, will have far less civilian harm than the standard procedure of dropping a bomb on whatever building they happen to be in.

Your thinking appears unreasonably binary here, as shown by your use of phrases like "zero consideration" and "definitely no consideration," in reaction to Israel not meeting an unrealistically high standard for "minimizing civilian harm." Could Israel have done more to minimize civilian harm with that attack? Perhaps, but that doesn't mean they did nothing.


Replies

Cyph0n12/11/2025

So it’s either drop a bomb on them or mass detonate explosive devices? Love it.

show 1 reply