logoalt Hacker News

IshKebab • last Thursday at 11:43 AM • 1 reply • view on HN

> In html you can just view comments as another node in a uniform tree.

When you parse an AST with comments (or a CST), they do become "just another node in a uniform tree". Think about it - in HTML you have a tree of nodes but comments can be anywhere, which is exactly as obnoxious to deal with as a CST where comment nodes can be anywhere.

This is a terrible reason to not support comments. If it was really important, then probably you should support comments in only a couple of places, e.g. on attributes or on selectors.

But I don't think it is very important. I can't think of a single tool that loads CSS, rearranges it, and then spits it back out in a form that would benefit from comments.

Replies

matt_kantor • last Thursday at 5:08 PM

> in HTML you have a tree of nodes but comments can be anywhere

Maybe I'm misunderstanding, but no they can't. For example the comment here is not a comment, but part of the URL:

    <a href="https://example.com<!-- comment -->">click me</a>
And HTML like this is simply broken:

    <div<!-- comment -->>content</div>
Maybe you meant "they can be anywhere that a Node can be in the DOM", but I think that's more or less what the CSS "mistake" is suggesting should be true about CSS (just replace "DOM" with "CSSOM").
➕ show 1 reply