logoalt Hacker News

MattGaiseryesterday at 4:18 PM1 replyview on HN

Probably because many are purists. It is like how anything about improving Electron devolves into "you shouldn't use Electron."

Many would consider this a bare minimum rather than something worthy of praise.


Replies

mschuster91yesterday at 4:45 PM

> Probably because many are purists. It is like how anything about improving Electron devolves into "you shouldn't use Electron."

The Electron debate isn't about details purism, the Electron debate is about the foundation being a pile of steaming dung.

Electron is fine for prototyping, don't get me wrong. It's an easy and fast way to ship an application, cross-platform, with minimal effort and use (almost) all features a native app can, without things like CORS, permission popups, browser extensions or god knows what else getting in your way.

But it should always be a prototype and eventually be shifted to native applications because in the end, unlike Internet Explorer in its heyday which you could trivially embed as ActiveX and it wouldn't lead to resource gobbling, if you now have ten apps consuming 1GB RAM each just for the Electron base to run, now the user runs out of memory because it's like PHP - nothing is shared.

show 3 replies