logoalt Hacker News

ivanovmlast Thursday at 5:03 PM7 repliesview on HN

this has ai writing smell all over it. entire paragraphs that just say it's-not-this-it's-that over and over again


Replies

forbiddenvoidlast Thursday at 5:22 PM

It's a construct that long predates AI. And using it with such intensity and frequency is more likely a sign that this _wasn't_ AI generated, since AI writing tends to _not_ repeat things quite so often.

show 1 reply
jnoveklast Thursday at 5:18 PM

Why does it matter? The information in the post still accurately captures a sentiment held by many people.

show 1 reply
grimgrinlast Thursday at 5:15 PM

perhaps it is the nature of their thought process

perhaps they blur their poetry

did they use an LLM in 2020: https://www.ithoughtaboutthatalot.com/2020/how-much-the-worl...

gryfftlast Thursday at 5:20 PM

I had the same reaction. The disclaimer at the bottom doesn't mention AI, but I have a feeling this was generated from a prompt to consolidate the 24 human submissions into a single essay.

Tangentially, I really look forward to the day "Not X but Y" stops being so overused by LLMs. It's a valid and useful construction in a vacuum, one which we should be able to use, but its overuse has gone past semantic satiety into something like semantic emesis.

linhnslast Friday at 7:01 PM

this comment has ai writing smell all over it.

BoredPositronlast Thursday at 5:46 PM

Most of the "this is AI" complaints demonstrate the illiteracy of many of those making them.

show 1 reply