logoalt Hacker News

gnulllast Friday at 6:28 PM1 replyview on HN

What makes the simulation we live in special compared to the simulation of a burning candle that you or I might be running?

That simulated candle is perfectly melting wax in its own simulation. Duh, it won't melt any in ours, because our arbitrary notions of "real" wax are disconnected between the two simulatons.


Replies

hnfonglast Friday at 6:46 PM

They do have a valid subtle point though.

If we don't think the candle in a simulated universe is a "real candle", why do we consider the intelligence in a simulated universe possibly "real intelligence"?

Being a functionalist ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Functionalism_(philosophy_of_m... ) myself, I don't know the answer on the top of my head.

show 3 replies