logoalt Hacker News

overfeedlast Saturday at 12:00 AM2 repliesview on HN

I provided a range of leader:worker income/power ratios from 1:0 to 1:1 with no commentary whatsoever on outcomes, because my entire point is that the outcome doesn't matter: at some threshold value and below, the existence of the org itself is immoral. We don't have to agree on where that point is, but its existence shouldn't be up for debate, IMO.

I hope we can all agree that a slave plantation should not exist in 2025, regardless of whether it's making billions in quarterly profit, or hovering above insolvency. Paying workers at this plantation $0.01 per hour isn't okay, either, but if you keep adding $0.01/hr N times (and incrementally improve working conditions), you'll eventually arrive at the threshold I was describing.


Replies

Izkatalast Saturday at 1:27 AM

> I provided a range of leader:worker income/power ratios from 1:0 to 1:1 with no commentary whatsoever on outcomes

For a slight perspective change, the thing that leads to what they mentioned: They're saying you forgot about the range 1:1 to 0:1.

show 1 reply
FrustratedMonkylast Saturday at 12:57 PM

The threshold does exist. Doesn't the poverty line take into account local conditions for median food/rent prices?

So minimum wage should be enough to be above poverty line.

This would solve cases like walmart employees being in poverty and needing government assistance to live.