logoalt Hacker News

Rob Reiner has died

273 pointsby RickJWagnertoday at 3:54 AM177 commentsview on HN

Comments

mvkeltoday at 1:51 PM

As an aside, it's been fascinating reading the comments here about news media.

People want journalists to publish quickly AND only publish what’s fully verified.

They want anonymous sources named "in the spirit of truth," without grappling with the reality that doing so would instantly dry up anyone risking their job, or worse, to provide information.

They expect journalists to release raw information as soon as they have it, while simultaneously acting as perfect filters; never amplifying rumors, or being wrong, even as new facts emerge.

They want neutrality, except when neutrality conflicts with their priors.

It's no wonder that morale among journalists is at an all-time low. Is any other profession held to such an impossible standard?

show 13 replies
benzibletoday at 6:04 AM

Reportedly killed by their son, who had struggled with addiction: https://people.com/rob-reiner-wife-michele-were-killed-by-so...

> In a 2016 interview with PEOPLE, Nick spoke about his years-long struggle with drug addiction, which began in his early teens and eventually left him living on the streets. He said he cycled in and out of rehab beginning around age 15, but as his addiction escalated, he drifted farther from home and spent significant stretches homeless in multiple states.

Rob Reiner directed a movie from a semi-autobiographical script his son co-wrote a few years ago. Hard to imagine many things worse than going through the pain of having a kid who seemed lost, getting him back, and then whatever must have been going on more recently that apparently led to this.

show 3 replies
ilamonttoday at 1:56 PM

There’s a really good interview with Rob Reiner on Fresh Air, recorded as Spinal Tap 2 was being released a few months back. He talks all about the many movies he’s worked on as well as growing up in the household of a comedian. Well worth 45 minutes of your time:

https://www.npr.org/programs/fresh-air/g-s1-87790/fresh-air-...

mellosoulstoday at 6:41 AM

I'd forgotten what an unusually strong and culturally-resonant line of movies the man had without (I think) the popular acclaim you might associate with them, like a low-profile Spielberg.

Spinal Tap

The Princess Bride

When Harry Met Sally

Sleepless in Seattle

Stand By Me

etc

A great loss, RIP

show 4 replies
llbbddtoday at 6:50 AM

Rest in peace. "The Princess Bride" is a really fun, unique and beautiful piece of art that my wife and I revisit all the time. Nobody deserves to go like this and he'll be missed.

show 1 reply
teddy-smithtoday at 2:29 PM

Journalism has always been hated by those in power and by proxy their followers.

It's arguable thats a sign that they're doing a good job.

Few profession I have more respect for than journalists and police.

Most of them are trying to fight evil and make society better and are disliked for it.

They are a gritty grizzled bunch.

show 1 reply
BLKNSLVRtoday at 5:45 AM

Three great movies that he directed that everyone around my age would be relatively intimately familiar with: This Is Spinal Tap, The Princess Bride and When Harry Met Sally

> Police are treating the deaths as apparent homicides. According to the L.A. Times, authorities have questioned a member of Reiner’s family in connection with the death. As of Sunday night, the LAPD have not officially identified a suspect, but Rolling Stone has confirmed that Reiner’s son, Nick, was involved in the homicide. A source confirmed to Rolling Stone that the couple’s daughter, Romy, found her parents’ bodies.

Alternative source:

> Senior law enforcement officials report that both had stab wounds

Tragic.

show 2 replies
delichontoday at 5:02 AM

He is still Archie Bunker's annoying son in law to me. I hear he did some interesting things since then though.

My best friend died in a family murder like this. A decade later the wounds of the survivors haven't healed.

At least Carl didn't live to suffer this.

show 1 reply
Liotoday at 9:59 AM

This is very sad news.

No one else has mentioned it but among all his other great performances his hair-trigger angry dad in Wolf of Wall Street is hilarious.

I think being able to be both funny in his anger but also a bit intimidating and then go to being a warm father figure is something he would not have been able to portray without genuine charisma.

jedbergtoday at 9:08 AM

FWIW, if you have HBOMax, you can watch what is now, sadly, his final film, Spinal Tap 2. It just arrived there yesterday.

(They also just got the original if you want to watch it again)

deegtoday at 4:43 PM

RIP Rob Reiner. The Princess Bride is one of my all-time favorite movies. I have a theory (born out by experience) that most American-born software engineers can quote at least one line from TBL. I often use it as an opener with new hires.

Death can not stop true love. It can only delay it for a while.

hypeateitoday at 5:23 PM

According to POTUS, he died because of Trump Derangement Syndrome[0]. Very classy and totally normal behavior from our highest office.

0: https://truthsocial.com/@realDonaldTrump/posts/1157241415688...

show 1 reply
lizknopetoday at 12:42 PM

I just watched Spinal Tap 2 last week and enjoyed it.

RIP Rob and Michelle.

show 1 reply
_alayatoday at 6:31 AM

Completely tragic. Rob Reiner's movies brought so much good into people's lives. The Princess Bride still remains a favorite. Today is a very sad and inconceivable end.

anshumankmrtoday at 1:25 PM

I only knew him from directing Harry Met Sally and Wolf of Wall street where almost all of his scenes are hillarious, especially the one where he burst into the room abusing DiCaprio and his gang over expenses.

RIP.

show 1 reply
kalterdevtoday at 6:42 AM

Thanks for The Princess Bride and Sleepless in Seattle. Rest in peace.

PaulDavisThe1sttoday at 4:00 PM

I'm not going to link to it, but the POTUS posted overnight about this, and even by the standards of that particular social media account, it was probably a new low. Someone in another forum I read regularly said of it "I'm going to show this to my kids to help teach them what the word sociopath means". It's not even the usual "politicizing a tragedy", just the complete inhumanity and self-centeredness on display. Look it up yourself if you want, but bring a bag.

show 2 replies
donatjtoday at 10:10 AM

Oh dang. Last night before falling asleep my wife told me "some guy from Spinal Tap died" while scrolling on her phone. Didn't think much of it.

Wake up and first thing I do is read this...

Rob Reiner? Really? What a terrible shame. What a loss. His films and even his time on All in the Family really helped shape the cultural landscape.

Nothing had as large an impact on my sense of humor growing up as This is Spinal Tap. Just thinking about the movie now I chuckle to myself. Most of his other films are certified classics.

He will be greatly missed.

show 1 reply
alsetmusictoday at 12:14 PM

Well that's just terrible. I went to a trade school for learning audio engineering. One of the instructors always used a day to show "Spinal Tap" to his class. I didn't realize it was fiction for about the first 40m. The guy made some great films.

show 2 replies
locusofselftoday at 6:37 AM

So sad. To me, he's primarily the "Spinal Tap" guy, but he did so much more.

show 1 reply
auggierosetoday at 6:21 AM

Jesus Christ. "When Harry met Sally" is easily the best romcom of all times.

show 2 replies
nephihahatoday at 10:07 AM

Terrible. I enjoyed many of his films, and count Spinal Tap, Misery and Stand by Me among my favourites. Rest in Peace!

spacechild1today at 1:12 PM

RIP! What a terrible way to go...

jongjongtoday at 8:54 AM

[flagged]

excaliburtoday at 1:34 PM

[flagged]

butterlettucetoday at 6:59 AM

“What da fu*k you sayin? Jordan, are you f*ckin’ high?!”

RIP

thx4explainingtoday at 3:02 PM

I'd like to honor Rob Reiner and This is Spinal Tap by mentioning my work and other peoples' successful projects:

Jimmy Fallon, manager, and band Stillwater in the film "Almost Famous".

Ari Gold in Entourage

And Wayne's World, I would have to say.