logoalt Hacker News

xandriusyesterday at 10:46 AM2 repliesview on HN

Not to disagree with your point but why does literally any discussion must have a mention of AI/LLMs?

Is it possible not to bring them up and still have a deep conversation?


Replies

fl4tul4yesterday at 11:21 AM

I guess the whole discussion (in 1963, in 2025), is about 'knowledge acquisition' (or lack thereof). He mentions the Brazilian students memorising 'stuff' without understanding - as a former Brazilian educator, I can tell you that when I was working there in 2010-2020, it hadn't changed, and, to my point, got worse in late years. I think a lot of students care about 'getting a diploma' without actually learning something, but my main concern is about fairness: how could I praise good students from 'devious' students altogether?

show 1 reply
rramadassyesterday at 12:26 PM

> why does literally any discussion must have a mention of AI/LLMs?

Your sentiment is right but in this case not applicable.

A Teacher who did not really understand what he was teaching can easily have LLMs generate lectures/notes/etc. and pass it along to students without any thought put into it. A Student on his part can simply have LLMs generate answers for all of his problem sets and pass it along to the teacher.

The above would be a disaster for the overall spread of Science in the Society.

show 1 reply