logoalt Hacker News

LanceHlast Monday at 3:56 PM2 repliesview on HN

Referees, who are seemingly out to make both sides lose.


Replies

mvkellast Monday at 5:57 PM

A referee is a perfect analogy. We love to rate an umpire's call as "bad" after watching the slow motion replay 25 times, not based on the split second one-shot of information they had when they made it.

DonHopkinslast Monday at 4:27 PM

Yeah but sports aren't essential to society, and it really doesn't matter who wins, beyond fanning the flames of tribalism and religious proxy battles and advertising endorsements and gambling and hooliganism.

But education and journalism are deeply and essentially beneficial to society.

Referees could just as well be replaced by a coin toss or AI or participation trophies (like FIFA Peace Prizes), and society would be just fine without them.

Their salaries are much better spent on journalists and teachers, and schools should spend much less on their sports programs and scholarships, and much more on their faculty and research and writing and journalism programs, to actually benefit students who are there to learn instead of just playing games.

show 1 reply