logoalt Hacker News

1718627440last Tuesday at 3:28 PM2 repliesview on HN

It is a political not a technical decision. Essentially the same like the Linux kernel not encouraging the use of out-of-tree kernel modules. https://gcc.gnu.org/legacy-ml/gcc/2000-01/msg00572.html


Replies

surajrmallast Tuesday at 3:37 PM

And it shows how silly the idea is. gcc still sees plenty of forks from vendors who don't upstream, and llvm sees a lot more commercial participation. Unfortunately the Linux kernel equivalent doesn't exist.

show 3 replies
chuckadamslast Tuesday at 6:56 PM

Linux's position is more like "your out-of-tree code is not our problem". Linus didn't go out of his way to make out-of-tree modules more difficult to write.