logoalt Hacker News

j45last Tuesday at 7:20 PM2 repliesview on HN

I have been told QEEG can offer an additional perspective in neurofeedback, etc as well.

fMRI's are being used in TBI/Concussion recovery that are study backed and seem to be delivering results.


Replies

D-Machinelast Tuesday at 7:29 PM

Yes, there are a few medical cases where fMRI makes good simple basic sense, and TBI/Concussion sounds immediately like one of those to me. I seem also to recall them being useful in some cases prior to brain surgeries and the like.

This all makes sense because fMRI tracks metabolic activity via oxygenation changes, which is much more clearly and plausibly related to tissue health and recovery. In these cases, it is also most likely being used within-subject (i.e. longitudinally) to make comparisons to baselines, rather than in an attempt to make speculative inferences about the mind using groups of people, and likely is a simple comparison to baseline rather than bespoke statistical analyses relying on questionable assumptions about the BOLD response being related to overly-specific kinds of neural activity.

show 1 reply
hirvi74last Tuesday at 7:57 PM

> fMRI's are being used in TBI/Concussion recovery

Interesting. Do you happen to have any more information on this topic? I ask because I was under the impression that concussions are a functional/metabolic injury and not a structural injury, therefore, concussions are not visible on any type of fMRI, CT Scan, etc.. Though, I haven't looked into this topic for almost half a decade, so I imagine things have likely progressed.

show 2 replies