logoalt Hacker News

mathattacktoday at 12:56 PM5 repliesview on HN

This seemed inevitable, no?

I’d love to see long term usage data on MOOCs. They had so much promise though I don’t know anyone who uses them post-LLM though it could be I live in a bubble.


Replies

ghafftoday at 1:19 PM

I'm not sure how much it has to do with LLMs.

It feels more like it was sort of a fad thing and, especially once any certification value essentially fell off the back of the truck (and therefore no one really willing to pay)--much less any real value delivered to people who weren't already autodidacts--it sort of faded away.

From where I was at the time Linkedin Learning (or whatever it was called) was a sometimes vaguely useful company benefit for random stuff but I'm not sure to what degree anyone even tracked who used it.

show 1 reply
HPsquaredtoday at 1:14 PM

LLMs could be a boost to MOOCs because you can use them as a tutor to help with the material. People tend to have trouble finishing MOOCs, and it can be frustrating to get stuck on a particular aspect without much instructor support. Anything that makes it more interactive could help with both of those. I think LLMs are a great complement to MOOCs.

brobdingnagianstoday at 1:00 PM

I use Udemy courses all the time; great for compliance, game engine training, and insightful training of soft skills. Good instructors have insight and comprehensive coverage that questioning LLMs do not have.

show 1 reply
Xenoamorphoustoday at 12:59 PM

LLMs typically still require some interactivity, no? Much easier to watch some videos in many cases.

show 4 replies
throwawaysleeptoday at 1:18 PM

One of the challenges is that few people are genuinely interested in a comprehensive view of a topic. Most of the time, I want just enough to get to the next step and get rid of a problem.

I never wish to learn about Docker. I want to know enough to get my containers running. In a pre-LLM world, I did take a course on Docker. I have learned my last bit of Docker in an LLM world.