logoalt Hacker News

zamalekyesterday at 6:14 PM1 replyview on HN

> Anybody who thought the simple action of rewriting things in Rust would eliminate all bugs was hopelessly naive

All bugs is typically a strawman typically only used by detractors. The correct claim is: safe Rust eliminates certain classes of bugs. I'd wager the design of std eliminates more (e.g. the different string types), but that doesn't really apply to the kernel.


Replies

samdoesnothingyesterday at 6:42 PM

> All bugs is typically a strawman typically only used by detractors. The correct claim is: safe Rust eliminates certain classes of bugs. I'd wager the design of std eliminates more (e.g. the different string types), but that doesn't really apply to the kernel.

Which is either 1) not true as evidenced by this bug or 2) a tautology whereby Rust eliminates all bugs that it eliminates.

show 2 replies