logoalt Hacker News

zimpenfishlast Wednesday at 8:22 PM1 replyview on HN

> The founders thought very hard about who should exercise which powers and how they should be selected.

Which would be perfectly fine as a basis if we were still in the 18th century.

Things are, I believe, somewhat different now and what a bunch of rich old white men thought then isn't all that relevant now except as a historical oddity.


Replies

rayinerlast Wednesday at 8:56 PM

If you think what the founders said doesn’t matter because they’re dead white guys, isn’t that an argument for giving more power to the guy who won the election? Because surely the dead hand of the founders is the only thing that has the authority to overrule the elected President.

It has to be a dichotomy, right? You either go by what the constitution meant to those who wrote it, because that’s how written agreements work, or otherwise you go with what the mob wants. How can there be some third option?

show 1 reply