logoalt Hacker News

pcaharrierlast Wednesday at 8:45 PM1 replyview on HN

Well, yes, the office of president was created to be weak relative to the British monarchy. But the substance of executive power (i.e., what actions are authorized) isn't really the issue, but rather whether anyone other than the president has the constitutional authority to do those things.

Take, for instance, the executive power "to grant Reprieves and Pardons for Offences against the United States" (Art. 2, Sec. 2). There is a pardon attorney who advises the president, but it is solely the president who has the executive power to grant the pardon; in that sense the president exercises the pardon power exclusively (or phrased differently "to the absolute exclusion of others").


Replies

estearumlast Wednesday at 11:40 PM

I mean the structure is clear as day:

Congress writes the laws, the executive (led by the President) executes them.

Not sure what your pardon example is meant to illustrate.

show 1 reply