logoalt Hacker News

Aurornislast Thursday at 2:45 PM2 repliesview on HN

> I’ve certainly seen a sharp increase on execs calling BS on dev teams saying they need months to develop some basic thing.

Some of the teams I worked with in the years right before AI coding went mainstream had become really terrible about this. They would spend months forming committees, writing documents, getting sign-offs and approvals, creating Gantt charts, and having recurring meetings for the simplest requests.

Before I left, they were 3 months deep into meetings about setting up role based access control on a simple internal CRUD app with a couple thousand users. We needed about 2-3 roles. They were into pros and cons lists for every library and solution they found, with one of the front runners involving a lot of custom development for some reason.

Yet the entire problem could have been solved with 3 Boolean columns in the database for the 3 different roles. Any developer could have done it in an afternoon, but they were stuck in a mindset of making a big production out of the process.

I feel like LLMs are good at getting those easy solutions done. If the company really only needs a simple change, having an LLM break free from the molasses of devs who complicate everything is a breath of fresh air.

On the other hand, if the company had an actual complicated need with numerous and changing roles over time, the simple Boolean column approach would have been a bad idea. Having people who know when to use each solution is the real key.


Replies

cmiles8last Thursday at 5:09 PM

Yes. I’ve seen meetings where the dev team is going on and on about how it will take weeks to add a feature and someone calling BS just shares their screen, asks some AI agent to code it up, and it does. Is it 100% perfect? Perhaps not, but is close and does put the dev team in a spot of having to truly justify why it will take so long vs hand-wavy smoke and mirrors and “its technical you wouldn’t understand” commentary to leadership. Things have changed and I don’t think we’re going back.

Seattle3503last Thursday at 6:53 PM

I think the "just do it" mindset requires management who understands that follow up requests might need to clean things up and refactor. I think some engineers have been traumatized by repeated applications of "just do it" and try to avoid technical debt up front, which is really really hard unless you are a SME with years of experience on building that exact thing.