The requirements in this article are... the bare minimum for a PR. Like yeah it needs to work is the no duh requirement. I have seen tons of PRs that work but defy conventions or add a bunch of useless cruft that we can rip out once I sit down and talk with them about what they did.

When someone pings me for a review and their code isn't even passing CI builds/tests I just let them know its failing and don't even look at a line of their code.