logoalt Hacker News

jfindperlast Thursday at 5:39 PM2 repliesview on HN

The fun thing about the computer fraud and abuse act is that just about anything can be made into a federal crime with it!


Replies

pcaharrierlast Thursday at 6:14 PM

Just about, indeed!

"Nonprofit hires woman, but she quits after a few days, asks for pay for that time; they refuse, and things get worse from there. But! They don’t turn off her email access to a board member’s email. She and a friend comb through the account, download internal documents, and then ask for a lot of money. Federal crime? Third Circuit: Not until they actually revoked her access."

https://www2.ca3.uscourts.gov/opinarch/233017p.pdf

Someone1234last Thursday at 5:49 PM

Considering it was created during a major moral panic after the movie "War Games" came out, by a bunch of politicians who knew nothing about computers (aside from, again, watching the movie War Games).

As a direct result, anything and everything can be a crime (e.g. violating a private company's Terms & Conditions), and the punishments are completely disproportionate to the actual criminality.

See the AT&T/iPad data leak, where AT&T were leaking private information on the internet with no security checks at all. Someone found it, told the press, who in turn told AT&T, but the FBI still investigated it as a "crime", raided their home, charged them with "conspiracy to access a computer without authorization." AT&T go no punishment at all.

show 1 reply