logoalt Hacker News

lenerdenatortoday at 5:41 PM2 repliesview on HN

Is there some provision that enabled the executive branch to keep extending the purchase deadline?

If not, the sale is illegal. Congress passed a law saying that TikTok was to be banned. Not "can be sold after a bunch of backroom deals by tech aristocracy that happens to be friends with an incredibly corrupt President", but banned. SCOTUS agreed that the law held up to scrutiny.


Replies

advisedwangtoday at 5:56 PM

The law [1] does not work as an magic all encompassing "ban". It says operating and distributing the app is is unlawful, and the consequence is a huge fine and the enforcement mechanism is suit from the US AG. Nothing says that a sale after doing something unlawful is illegal.

The bigger issue is that the Trump directed the AG not to enforce the law. So something is plainly illegal but is de-facto legal because of executive pronouncement. That is extremely worrying because one aspect of totalitarianism is that the dicta of the ruler has effect of law.

[1] https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/house-bill/815/...

spencerflemtoday at 7:44 PM

Yeah it’s illegal. What are you gonna do about it