logoalt Hacker News

tomwwlast Friday at 10:18 PM2 repliesview on HN

They're using a graph neural network. From the article - "The team leveraged Google DeepMind's GraphCast model as an initial foundation and fine-tuned the model using NOAA's own Global Data Assimilation System analyses".

> so what’s AI about this that wasn’t AI previously?

The weather models used today are physics-based numerical models. The machine learning models from DeepMind, ECMWF, Huawei and others are a big shift from the standard, numerical approach used for the last decades.


Replies

padjoyesterday at 12:35 AM

Thanks, I guess my assumption that ML was widely used in forecasting is wrong.

So are they essentially training a neural net on a bunch of weather data and getting a black box model that is expensive to train but comparatively cheap to run?

Are there any other benefits? Like is there a reason to believe it could be more accurate than a physics model with some error bars?

show 2 replies
bee_rideryesterday at 2:53 AM

Do these ML models replace the numerical approach completely? A lot of numerical methods are iterative. If the ML model can produce a good initial guess, it might make convergence of an iterative process quite a bit quicker…