logoalt Hacker News

dhpeyesterday at 10:53 AM6 repliesview on HN

I have programmed 30K+ hours. Do LLMs make bad code: yes all the time (at the moment zero clue about good architecture). Are they still useful: yes, extremely so. The secret sauce is that you'd know exactly what to do without them.


Replies

dejvyesterday at 2:09 PM

"Do LLMs make bad code: yes all the time (at the moment zero clue about good architecture). Are they still useful: yes, extremely so."

Well, lets see how all the economics will play out. LLMs might be really useful, but as far as I can see all the AI companies are not making money on inference alone. We might be hitting plateau in capabilities with money being raised on vision of being this godlike tech that will change the world completely. Sooner or later the costs will have to meet the reality.

show 8 replies
qsortyesterday at 11:07 AM

One of the mental frameworks that convinced me is how much of a "free action" it is. Have the LLM (or the agent) churn on some problem and do something else. Come back and review the result. If you had to put significant effort into each query, I agree it wouldn't be worth it, but you can just type something into the textbox and wait.

_rpxpxyesterday at 11:11 AM

OK, maybe. But how many programmers will know this in 10 years' time as use of LLMs is normalized? I like to hear what employers are saying already about recent graduates.

show 5 replies
bilsbieyesterday at 3:39 PM

I mean if you leaned heavily on stack overflow before AI then nothing really changes.

It’s basically the same idea but faster.

feverzsjyesterday at 11:10 AM

So, it's like taking off your pants to fart.