logoalt Hacker News

raw_anon_1111last Saturday at 10:14 PM1 replyview on HN

What do you suggest? They just promote people based on tenure?


Replies

oh_my_goodnesslast Saturday at 10:23 PM

You've put a lot of words in my mouth, and I don't know why.

What do I suggest? I suggest that big organizations have pockets of careful, competent folks. But in general a large company tends to be all fouled up. They do a lot of things pretty much randomly. Some stuff happens the way a new graduate has a right to expect, and the way many HN commenters insist it has to go.

But a lot of other shit just ... happens. People get promoted because they have another offer from another fouled-up company, or because the boss thinks they're awesome (but sometimes the boss is dumb), or because they talk the talk exceptionally well, or because they happen to get the attention of someone 2 or 3 levels up, or whatever.

Is any of that controversial? What am I missing here?

Do people not still read Catch-22? Or has it been proved wrong or something? Or take that mysterious cactus that you mentioned in connection with large companies. What's that about? Because the cactus sounds bad.

show 1 reply