logoalt Hacker News

Brian_K_Whitetoday at 12:21 AM2 repliesview on HN

It's a lot of work to make models that are useful in real life, but for some things it's worth it because it's sooo nice having 2k of plain text that describes an entire object, and it's even fully parametric, and it even comes with a customizer panel for the parameters, so every model isn't just a model, it's a model generator app, and even has meaningful diffs in git.

The same model in freecad is like 6 megs of zipped xml and realistically not nearly as usefully parametric.

That couple-k of plain text is such a huge deal that it makes all the other difficulty worth it for mechanical/functional stuff.


Replies

bb88today at 12:35 AM

I find that I'm often making one-offs. I take a part I designed and I need a slight modification for it for some reason.

Fusion is great for that as long as there's not too many parts. But sometimes I'll want a new variant or a series of new variants.

And reaching for python makes that easy.

dheeratoday at 12:31 AM

OpenSCAD is the only CAD tool I use. I can'd figure out how to operate a graphical 3D software with a 2D GUI so it's just easier to describe things mathematically.

I just wish it had operations for subtractively chamfering, rounding, etc. as doing minkowski() with cones and spheres to achieve that result can be unwieldy.

show 1 reply