logoalt Hacker News

pmkarytoday at 9:45 AM5 repliesview on HN

I have many books from Chomsky, and I want to throw them away because it disgusts me to have them. Then I think, why should I throw away things I spent so much on? It makes me more angry. So I have pilled them up somewhere to figure out what ti do with them and each time I walk past it I feel sad to ever passed by his work.


Replies

IndySuntoday at 3:52 PM

Make sure to vet your entire circle - friends, relatives, books, movies, everything... it's going to take a while. In the meantime you'll stop learning/growing too.

Mine is as ludicrous a suggestion as it is to damn by association.

rixedtoday at 2:17 PM

Are you reacting with as much intensity when you walk past any scientific work older than 20 years?

eucyclostoday at 12:30 PM

There's an interview with Dan schmachtenberger where he talks about the worst book ever written (his opinion is that it's 'the 48 laws of power'). He made the point that being consistently wrong is actually pretty impressive, and there are worthwhile lessons from watching someone getting taken seriously despite being wrong. Maybe you could revisit them with that approach.

show 2 replies
f1shytoday at 10:42 AM

I assume this comes from his views in politics and/or association with things like Epstein. I would say, independent of that, some works of him can be very valuable. Private life of persons and their work, are better put in totally different context, and not mixed.

show 1 reply
andyjohnson0today at 10:45 AM

I don't understand. What is it about Chomsky's work that disgusts you? Or is this a reference to his political opinions?

show 1 reply