logoalt Hacker News

brepppyesterday at 5:54 PM5 repliesview on HN

Depends, the camera killed painting and is a positive for art in my opinion

It's not obvious that LLM generation won't create more interesting music experiences (for lack of non-marketing speak for self curated music)


Replies

galleywest200yesterday at 5:59 PM

The camera did not kill painting. There are tons and tons of painters still, lots of them use digital means like a tablet these days but it still absolutely exists.

show 1 reply
_fzslmyesterday at 6:16 PM

Arguably, the camera evolved painting because it expanded the idea of what it could be – that it could be more than the illustration of/"illusion" of reality.

I think and have always thought the exact same thing will happen with generative AI.

show 2 replies
bopbopbop7yesterday at 5:58 PM

The camera did not kill painting. And how does comparing a camera to an LLM even make sense?

show 2 replies
lm28469yesterday at 6:28 PM

> It's not obvious that LLM generation won't create more interesting music experiences

It's very obvious that it's polluting and/or killing everything it touched so far though

show 1 reply
freejazzyesterday at 6:25 PM

>Depends, the camera killed painting and is a positive for art in my opinion

Have you been to a contemporary art museum?

show 1 reply