logoalt Hacker News

Moravec's Paradox and the Robot Olympics

75 pointsby bekleinlast Tuesday at 1:39 PM9 commentsview on HN

Comments

bglazertoday at 3:23 AM

I genuinely did not expect to see a robot handling clothing like this within the next ten years at least. Insanely impressive

I do find it interesting that they state that each task is done with a fine tuned model. I wonder if that’s a limitation of the current data set their foundation model is trained on (which is what I think they’re suggesting in the post) or if it reflects something more fundamental about robotics tasks. It does remind me of a few years ago in LLMs when fine tuning was more prevalent. I don’t follow LLM training methodology closely but my impression was that the bulk of recent improvements have come from better RL post training and inference time reasoning.

Obviously they’re pursuing RL and I’m not sure spending more tokens at inference would even help for fine manipulation like this, notwithstanding the latency problems with that.

So, maybe the need for fine tuning goes away with a better foundation model like they’re suggesting? I hope this doesn’t point towards more fundamental limitations on robotics learning with the current VLA foundation model architectures

show 1 reply
Animatstoday at 2:12 AM

Those videos are very impressive. This is real progress on tasks at which robotics have been failing for fifty years.

Here are some of the same tasks being attempted as part of the DARPA ARM program in 2012.[1] Compare key-in-lock and door opening with the 2025 videos linked above. Huge improvement.

We just might be over the hump on manipulation.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jeABMoYJGEU

godelskitoday at 10:11 AM

  > The gold-medal task is to hang an inside-out dress shirt, after turning it right-side-in, which we do not believe our current robot can do physically, because the gripper is too wide to fit inside the sleeve
You don't need to fit inside the sleeve to turn it inside out...

Think about a sock (same principle will apply, but easier to visualize). You scrunch up the sock so it's like a disk. Then you pull to invert.

This can be done with any piece of clothing. It's something I do frequently because it's often easier (I turn all my clothes inside out before washing).

show 1 reply
chrisharetoday at 8:56 AM

Sergey Levine, one of the co-founders, sat for an excellent Dwarkesh podcast episode this year, which I thoroughly recommend.

DonHopkinstoday at 1:43 PM

The Turing Institute in Glasgow hosted the First Robot Olympics on 27–28 September 1990 at the Sports Centre at the University of Strathclyde, featuring 68 robots from 12 countries.

Our robotic overlords have come a long way in 35 years!

Check out the cool retro robot photos:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Robot_Olympics

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turing_Institute

My favorites:

Robug II disqualified for trying to mount Russian competitor during race.

Torchbearer NEL carrying flame to Olympic Venue from Greek Restaurant.

Walking pizza box Biped Walker, University of Wales. Paul Channon & Simon Hopkins.

The Seventh Incarnation of Dr Who (Sylvestor McCoy) opens the event with Sue Mowforth.

Richard 1st robot head commentator from The Turing Institute, Glasgow. (I use this as my Slack avatar!)

srousseytoday at 5:39 AM

Robolympics.ai