logoalt Hacker News

IlikeKittiesyesterday at 8:32 PM1 replyview on HN

It's a bit of a two edged sword but it's something we definitely need. Look at project like Qubes and Secureblue that try to implement this. It solves several issues:

Packaging Apps on Linux has been and always will be, a nightmare. Just giving up and sending whole VMs is basically a variant of what docker does.

Permission Management is also quite necessary and Linux Desktop/DBUS is horrible in that regard. There's recently been a post about this[0]. Especially part 5 is just... GNOME Developers being GNOME Developers...

A lot of Apps also open untrusted files and even run untrusted code. Browsers, PDFs, or Excel Macros? God only knows what kind of exploits and hidden software landmines there are.

And last but not least there's also just badly coded apps that can get pwned from remote sources. Think some game running horrible c++ code connecting peer to peer with random clients. All of them could easily buffer overflow some random function and take over all your files.

[0] https://blog.vaxry.net/articles/2025-dbusSucks


Replies

trinsic2today at 2:36 AM

Yea im sorry. Im not buying this. I dont need protection from apps on my system. I know you think we need it, but I dont believe we need it. creating security systems like this only complicates the operation of apps.